The Shami Dilemma: When Age Becomes a Barrier to Selection

The Indian cricket team’s selection committee has been under scrutiny for its handling of several players. Mohammed Shami, one of India’s most experienced fast bowlers, has not played for the national team since March 2025 and his continued absence raises questions about whether he will ever return.

Bharat Arun, former India bowling coach, has criticized the current selection committee led by Ajit Agarkar, stating that Shami’s exclusion was unwarranted. He points out that Shami has performed consistently well on the domestic circuit and his experience would still be valuable to the team.

The case of Shami reflects a broader trend in cricket where ageism seems to be increasing. With an emphasis on youth and fitness, older players are often seen as liabilities rather than assets. This raises questions about what constitutes “fitness” and whether age is being used as an excuse to sideline experienced players.

Shami’s absence has not gone unnoticed, particularly when compared to other players who have been given more opportunities despite similar records. Jasprit Bumrah has been out of action for several months but remains in the running for a spot in the national team. In contrast, Shami has performed well on the domestic circuit and his experience would seem to make him a valuable asset.

The public exchange between Shami and Agarkar last year added fuel to the fire. After being left out of the Test squad against the West Indies, Agarkar questioned Shami’s fitness, which Shami responded to by pointing out that he was still fit enough to play Ranji Trophy cricket for Bengal. This episode highlighted the tension between the selection committee and players who feel they have been unfairly treated.

Ishan Kishan, captain of East Zone, has spoken about Shami’s attitude and motivation. According to Kishan, Shami has shown a strong desire to make an India comeback and his intensity and energy on the field have been notable. This raises questions about whether the selection committee is paying attention to the right metrics when evaluating players.

Shami’s performance in the Duleep Trophy final, where he achieved 100 first-class matches, has provided another significant milestone. While this achievement is a testament to his enduring talent and dedication, it’s hard not to wonder what might have been if he had been given more opportunities by the national team.

As the Indian cricket team continues to evolve, striking a balance between youth and experience is essential. Shami’s case highlights the need for a more nuanced approach to selection, one that considers not just a player’s fitness but also their value to the team as a whole.